Selecting and Using Organic Fertilizers

Organic fertilizers are derived solely from the remains or byproducts of a once-living organism. One of the advantages of organic fertilizers is that they seldom burn plants due to their low analysis. The nutrients are released to plants relatively slowly over time, allowing for less frequent applications. As they decompose, they also improve soil structure. The disadvantages are that, as they release nutrients slowly, the nutrients may not be immediately available to plants.

garden compost by Paul Maguire/AdobeStock
Organic fertilizers come in many different forms or types such as compost.  (1)

Traditionally applied organic fertilizers are often bulky and may be difficult to handle. They are usually low in analysis and can vary greatly from source to source. For example, well-rotted animal manure is a common organic fertilizer. It varies widely in nutrient content depending on the species of the animal that produced it. Nutrients can also vary with the age and handling of the manure. 


Selecting Organic Fertilizers  |  Using Organic Fertilizers  |   Application Rates per 1,000 ft2  |  Application Rates per 100 ft2   | More Information


Selecting Organic Fertilizers

Use the tables below to select the appropriate fertilizers and application rates for your garden. The table lists the typical nitrogen-phosphorus-potassium (NPK) ratio, where relevant, as well as the content of other significant nutrients. It also lists the primary benefit of each fertilizer. Some supply particular nutrients, some help balance the content of soil minerals, and others are primarily useful to enrich the soil with organic matter.

Benefits and Average Analysis of Selected Organic Fertilizers

Benefits and Average Analysis of Selected Organic Fertilizers
Organic AmendmentPrimary BenefitAverage AnalysisComments
Alfalfa MealOrganic matter5-1-2Contains friaconatol, a naturally fatty acid growth stimulant, plus trace minerals
Apple PomaceOrganic matter0.2-0-0.2Contains trace minerals
AragoniteCalcium96% calcium carbonateCan replace limestone
Bat Gauno (ancient)Nitrogen 2-8-0Contains calcium
Bat Guano (fresh)Nitrogen10-3-1Contains calcium
BioActivatorOrganic matter1 billion beneficialbacterial spores per gramBeneficial bacteria to innoculate composts and green manure crops
Blood MealNitrogen10-0-0 
Bonemeal (steamed)Phosphate1-11-0; 20% total phosphate; 24% calcium 
BoraxTrace minerals10% boron  
Calcilic LimestoneBalancer, calcium65-80% calcium carbonate; 3-15% magnesium carbonate 
Coffee groundsNitrogen2-0.3-0.2Acid-forming; needs limestone supplement.
Colloidal phosphatePhosphate0-2-2  
Compost (dry commercial)Organic matter1-1-1 
Compost (homemade)Organic matter0.5-0.5-0.5 to 4-4-4; 25% organic matter 
Compost (mushroom)Organic matter Ask supplier whether the material contains pesticide residues.
Corn Stover (dry)Organic matter1.2-0.4-1.6 
Corn Stover (green)Organic matter0.3-0.1-0.3 High in sugars when tilled or dug in while still green.
Cottonseed MealNitrogen6-2-1May contain pesticide residues.
Cowpeas (dry)Organic matter3.1-0.6-2.3  
Crab MealNitrogen4.3-0.5 Also useful to help control harmful nematodes.
Dolomitic LimestoneBalancer, calcium, magnesium51% calcium carbonate; 40% magnesium carbonate 
Egg ShellsBalancer, magnesium1.2-0.4-0Contain calcium plus trace minerals.
Epsom SaltsBalancer, magnesium10% magnesium; 13% sulfurContains calcium
FeathermealsNitrogen4-1-1  
Fish EmulsionNitrogen4-1-1; 5% sulfur 
Fish MealNitrogen5-3-3 
Flowers of SulfurBalancer99.5% sulfur 
Granite MealPotash4% total potash; contains 67% silicas and 19 trace minerals 
Grass Clippings (green)Organic matter0.5-0.2-0.5 
GreensandPotash7% total postash plus 32 trace minerals 
GypsumBalancer, calcium22% calcium; 17% sulfurDo not apply if pH is below 5.8.
Hairy VetchOrganic matter2.8-0.8-2.3 
Hay, BluegrassOrganic matter1.8-0.6-1.8 
Hay, FescueOrganic matter2.1-0.7-2.4 
Hay, LespedezaOrganic matter 2.4-0.8-2.3 
Hay, Orchard GrassOrganic matter2.3-0.7-2.8 
Hay, Red CloverOrganic matter2.8-0.6-2.3 
Hay, Sweet CloverOrganic matter2.2-0.6-2.2  
Hay, TimothyOrganic matter1.8-0.7-2.8  
Hoof and Horn MealNitrogen12-2-0 
HumatesOrganic matterHumic acids of variable composition 
Kelp MealPotash, trace minerals1.5-0.5-2.5 
Manure, Cattle (dry)Organic matter2-2.3-2.4Should be composted or applied in the fall.
Manure, HorseOrganic matter1.7-0.7-1.8 
Manure, Poultry (dry)Organic matter4-4.2-0Should be composted
Manure, Sheep (dry)Organic matter4-1.4-3.5  
Manure, SwineOrganic matter2-1.8-1.8Should be composted or applied in the fall.
Oak LeavesOrganic matter0.8-9.4-0.1 
Oyster ShellsCalcium33.5% calcium 
Peat MossOrganic matterpH range 3.0-4.5Use around acid-loving plants.
Rock PhosphatePhosphate0-3-032% total phosphate; 32% calcium; contains 11 trace minerals
SawdustOrganic matter0.2-0-0.2Be sure sawdust is well-rotted before incorporating.
Soybean MealNitrogen7-0.5-2.3  
Straw, WheatOrganic matter0.7-0.2-1.2  
Sul-Po-MagPotash, magnesium0-0-22; 11% magnesium; 22% sulfurDo not use if applying dolomitic limestone; substitute greensand or other potassium
Wheat BranOrganic matter2.6-2.9-1.6  
White Clover (green)Organic matter0.5-0.2-0.3  
Wood Ashes (leached)Potash0-1.2-2  
Wood Ashes (unleached)Potash0-1.5-8  

gardener applying Fish Blood and Bone Meal fertiliser organic spring garden food By Maksims/AdobeStock
Bonemeal fertilizer (2)

Using Organic Fertilizers

Although the above references provide gardeners with general guidelines on nutrients in common organic fertilizers, it does not represent a guaranteed analysis.  When applying organic fertilizers, the best practice is to be conservative in your application. Experiment with the amount applied and observe how the plants respond. More nutrients can be added if needed, but an overzealous application cannot be easily undone.

Once the amount of organic fertilizer needed is determined, spread it over the garden area and incorporate it into the top 6 to 8 inches of soil. This can be done with a garden fork, spade, or tiller.  Fall is a good time to add manure to garden spaces.  Other organic fertilizers can be added throughout the growing season when needed.


Average Application Rates per 1,000 ft2  |  Average Application Rates per 100 ft2  


Average Applicable Rate per 1,000 square feet

Application rates for low, medium, or adequate fertility soils are meant to be used in conjunction with an assessment of your soil by a soil testing laboratory, as well as your personal observations and the specific requirements of the crops you are growing.

Average Applicable Rate per 1,000 square feet
Organic AmendmentLow FertilityMedium FertilityAdequate Fertility
Alfalfa Meal50 lbs35 lbs25 lbs
Apple Pomace250 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Aragonite100 lbs50 lbs25 lbs
Bat Gauno (ancient)25 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Bat Guano (fresh)30 lbs20 lbs10 lbs
BioActivator4 oz3 oz2 oz
Blood Meal30 lbs20 lbs10 lbs
Bonemeal (steamed)30 lbs20 lbs10 lbs
Borax5 oz4 oz3 oz
Calcilic Limestone100 lbs50 lbs25 lbs
Coffee groundsIncorporate in compost  
Colloidal phosphate60 lbs25 lbs10 lbs
Compost (dry commercial)200 lbs100 lbs50 lbs
Compost (homemade)2000 lbs1000 lbs400 lbs
Compost (mushroom)350 lbs250 lbs50 lbs
Corn Stover (dry)250 lbs150 lbslbs
Corn Stover (green)1000 lbs600 lbs400 lbs
Cottonseed Meal35 lbs25 lbs10 lbs
Cowpeas (dry)200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Crab Meal150 lbs100 lbs50 lbs
Dolomitic Limestone100 lbs50 lbs25 lbs
Egg Shells100 lbs50 lbs25 lbs
Epsom Salts5 lbs3 lbs1 lbs
Feathermeals30 lbs20 lbs10 lbs
Fish Emulsion2 oz1 oz1 oz
Fish Meal30 lbs20 lbs10 lbs
Flowers of Sulfur10 lbs5 lbs2 lbs
Granite Meal100 lbs50 lbs25 lbs
Grass Clippings (green)500 lbs300 lbs200 lbs
Greensand400 lbs50 lbs25 lbs
Gypsum40 lbs20 lbs5 lbs
Hairy Vetch200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Hay, Bluegrass250 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Hay, Fescue200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Hay, Lespedeza200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Hay, Orchard Grass200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Hay, Red Clover200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Hay, Sweet Clover200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Hay, Timothy200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Hoof and Horn Meal30 lbs20 lbs10 lbs
Humates50 lbs30 lbs15 lbs
Kelp Meal20 lbs10 lbs5 lbs
Manure, Cattle (dry)200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Manure, Horse200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Manure, Poultry (dry)100 lbs50 lbs25 lbs
Manure, Sheep (dry)100 lbs50 lbs25 lbs
Manure, Swine200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Oak Leaves250 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Oyster Shells100 lbs50 lbs25 lbs
Peat MossAs needed  
Rock Phosphate60 lbs25 lbs10 lbs
Sawdust250 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Soybean Meal50 lbs25 lbs10 lbs
Straw, Wheat250 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
Sul-Po-Mag10 lbs7 lbs5 lbs
Wheat Bran200 lbs150 lbs100 lbs
White Clover (green)800 lbs600 lbs400 lbs
Wood Ashes (leached)20 lbs10 lbs5 lbs
Wood Ashes (unleached)10 lbs5 lbs3 lbs

Average Applicable Rate per 100 square feet

Application rates for low, medium, or adequate fertility soils are meant to be used in conjunction with an assessment of your soil by a soil testing laboratory, as well as your personal observations and the specific requirements of the crops you are growing.

Average Applicable Rate per 100 square feet
Organic AmendmentLow FertilityMedium FertilityAdequate Fertility
Alfalfa Meal5 lbs3.5 lbs2.5 lbs
Apple Pomace25 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Aragonite10 lbs5 lbs2.5 lbs
Bat Gauno (ancient)2.5 lbs1.5 lbs1 lbs
Bat Guano (fresh)3 lbs2 lbs1 lbs
BioActivator6.4 oz4.8 oz3.2 oz
Blood Meal3 lbs2 lbs1 lbs
Bonemeal (steamed)3 lbs2 lbs1 lbs
Borax8 oz6.4 oz4.8 oz
Calcilic Limestone10 lbs5 lbs2.5 lbs
Coffee groundsIncorporate in compost  
Colloidal phosphate6 lbs2.5 lbs1 lbs
Compost (dry commercial)20 lbs10 lbs5 lbs
Compost (homemade)200 lbs100 lbs40 lbs
Compost (mushroom)35 lbs25 lbs5 lbs
Corn Stover (dry)25 lbs15 lbs0 lbs
Corn Stover (green)100 lbs60 lbs40 lbs
Cottonseed Meal3.5 lbs2.5 lbs1 lbs
Cowpeas (dry)20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Crab Meal15 lbs10 lbs5 lbs
Dolomitic Limestone10 lbs5 lbs2.5 lbs
Egg Shells10 lbs5 lbs2.5 lbs
Epsom Salts8 oz4.8 oz1.6 oz
Feathermeals3 lbs2 lbs1 lbs
Fish Emulsion0.2 lbs0.1 lbs0.1 lbs
Fish Meal3 lbs2 lbs1 lbs
Flowers of Sulfur16 oz8 oz3.2 oz
Granite Meal10 lbs5 lbs2.5 lbs
Grass Clippings (green)50 lbs30 lbs20 lbs
Greensand40 lbs5 lbs2.5 lbs
Gypsum4 lbs2 lbs0.5 lbs
Hairy Vetch20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Hay, Bluegrass25 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Hay, Fescue20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Hay, Lespedeza20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Hay, Orchard Grass20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Hay, Red Clover20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Hay, Sweet Clover20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Hay, Timothy20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Hoof and Horn Meal3 lbs2 lbs1 lbs
Humates5 lbs3 lbs1.5 lbs
Kelp Meal2 lbs1 lbs0.5 lbs
Manure, Cattle (dry)20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Manure, Horse20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Manure, Poultry (dry)10 lbs5 lbs2.5 lbs
Manure, Sheep (dry)10 lbs5 lbs2.5 lbs
Manure, Swine20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Oak Leaves25 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Oyster Shells10 lbs5 lbs2.5 lbs
Peat MossAs needed  
Rock Phosphate6 lbs2.5 lbs1 lbs
Sawdust25 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Soybean Meal5 lbs2.5 lbs1 lbs
Straw, Wheat25 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
Sul-Po-Mag16 oz11.2 oz8 oz
Wheat Bran20 lbs15 lbs10 lbs
White Clover (green)80 lbs60 lbs40 lbs
Wood Ashes (leached)2 lbs1 lbs0.5 lbs
Wood Ashes (unleached)16 oz8 oz4.8 oz


More Information


Photo credits: 1: Paul Maguire/AdobeStock  2: Maksims/AdobeStock

Authors:
Last reviewed:
October 2025