Aster Yellows wreaking havoc in Iowa - What gives?

Aster yellows infected coneflower
Figure 1. Example of what a very typical presentation of aster yellows looks like on purple coneflower

Aster yellows was confirmed in Iowa in 2010 for the first time. Not to be confused with the damage associated with Aster Rosette Eriophyid mites, aster yellows is caused by a phytoplasma that is transmitted from plant to plant by aster leafhopper feeding. And in 2024, based on symptoms shared in social media posts in Iowa gardening groups (Fig. 1), aster yellows in running rampant in Iowa. Before we dig into why this might be such a problem this year, let’s review a bit about the disease. 

Distorted growth in the form of phyllody, which appears as vegetative tissue growing in the place of floral tissues, is the most characteristic symptom of aster yellows in perennial flower gardens. Symptoms on other hosts can vary, including dwarfed, yellowish growth. The symptoms of phyllody in purple coneflowers tend to be especially distinct (Fig. 2). The phytoplasma that causes this aster yellows can cause disease in over 300 plant species. 

Aster yellows infected coneflower.
Figure 2. This symptom on purple coneflower is called phyllody- when vegetative tissue replaces floral tissues

However, we’ve only been able to find a publication with a partial host list

Once a plant is infected with aster yellows, there is no cure. The impacted plants must be removed completely (including roots) and destroyed. Because of the wide host range (many which can be found in perennial gardens), finding plants with aster yellows symptoms in your garden can be especially troubling. 

So what gives this year? As mentioned, this phytoplasma (bacteria-like) pathogen is transmitted from plant to plant by leafhopper feeding, primarily the aster leafhopper. 

Aster leafhopper populations, like the populations of all insects, vary naturally from year to year based on several factors, like weather and rainfall. Aster leafhopper is a bit more unique in that the individuals we experience in Iowa primarily migrate for the winter to more southern locations and must make the trip back the following spring. Thus, factors such as wind events, primarily winds from the south, at times during migration could result in higher populations. 

Winter temperatures were warmer across much of the U.S. this past winter (Fig. 3 and Fig. 4). This could have resulted in additional survivorship of aster leafhoppers and other insects (however, some insects could experience less survivorship during warmer winters). In several locations across Iowa, however, there have been significant gusty wind events during the migration period of the aster leafhopper. These wind events could have propelled additional leafhoppers into more northern locations this summer, thus providing additional populations in fields and an increase in transmission of the phytoplasma that causes aster yellows. This is purely speculation, of course, as the exact causes of increased insect populations year-to-year is challenging to prove. We also have limited data on the number of leafhoppers in fields this year. 

Daily High/Low temperature graph for the Des Moines, Iowa area in 2024.
Figure 3. During spring, daily high temperatures were fairly consistently above average. Since the end of May, temperatures in Des Moines stayed closer to average. This plot shows the daily high and low temperature observed in Des Moines since January 1, 2024, compared to the average range of high/low temperatures (green area). When temperatures remain within the green area, they are within the average temperature range for that day of the year, and temperatures outside of that range are below (blue) or above (red) the average daily range.
Des Moines Area Year 2024 daily high temperature departure graph.
Figure 4. Greatest temperature departures occurred at the beginning of this year. One day in February had a temperature 40 degrees above average. Many days this spring recorded temperatures above average, as shown by this plot. July has seen more daily high temperatures below than above average.
Windrose plot for Des Moines Iowa between May 1, 2024 and July 25, 2024.
Figure 5. A wind rose describes the percent of time wind blew from a certain direction and its speed. Between May and July in Des Moines, wind generally came from the southeast at a speed of 5-15 miles per hour.

Links to this article are strongly encouraged, and this article may be republished without further permission if published as written and if credit is given to the author, Yard and Garden, and Iowa State University Extension and Outreach. If this article is to be used in any other manner, permission from the author is required. This article was originally published on August 8, 2024. The information contained within may not be the most current and accurate depending on when it is accessed.